.jpg)
The Critical Role of Cost Estimation
Precision is a necessity for cost engineers. Whether estimating the cost of a new satellite system or projecting the budget for a defense contract, a miscalculation can mean millions of dollars lost, contracts jeopardized, or critical missions delayed. The Basis of Estimate (BOE) document is a required and important component to successful cost estimation in this environment.
What is a BOE?
A Basis of Estimate (BOE) is one of the most important parts of a proper response to a Government Solicitation. It is a comprehensive document that explains the methodology, assumptions, and reasoning behind the cost estimate for the project. It provides the context for how the estimate was developed and ensures transparency, making it easier for project stakeholders to evaluate the estimate’s credibility and reliability.
A Well-Crafted BOE
Creating a transparent narrative that justifies figures is the foundation of the BOE. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) emphasizes the importance of comprehensive documentation, which builds the credibility of an estimate and ensures that it withstands scrutiny from internal auditors, external reviewers, and the stakeholders who leverage it.
The BOE should not just be a formality or checking a box. The BOE captures the rationale behind assumptions, the source of data, and the methodology behind calculations. It’s a document that should be as precise as the engineering calculations it supports and as clear as a well-told story that non-experts can follow.
The Challenges of Creating a BOE
Creating a BOE that meets these standards isn’t simple. One of the primary challenges lies in achieving true transparency. A BOE compiles historical data, expert judgment, and statistical analysis. However, achieving this level of transparency requires a deep dive into the data, often involving collaboration between experts.
Another challenge is maintaining credibility while dealing with uncertainties. GovCons are characterized by complex technologies where uncertainties are the norm rather than the exception. Documenting these uncertainties in a BOE without underplaying or overstating them is a delicate process. The BOE provides a realistic assessment of risks and uncertainties, laying out potential impacts clearly and concisely.
Critical Elements of a Credible BOE:
- Detailed Rationale: Assumptions and data points are thoroughly explained to ensure transparency.
- Traceability: Tracking estimates back to their sources and methodologies enhances credibility.
- Risk Mitigation: Documenting potential risks and uncertainties allows for proactive management and adjustment.
- Stakeholder Communication: The BOE translates complex technical information into clear, understandable language for all stakeholders.
Moreover, the BOE is the communication bridge between cost engineers and stakeholders with differing technical expertise. Translating complex engineering estimates into understandable and actionable terms for decision-makers is a skill in itself. The BOE should be crafted with the foresight that it may be scrutinized by people far removed from the engineering processes.
The BOE and Project Integrity
The BOE functions as a benchmark against which project progress is measured. When deviations from the original estimate occur—as they almost inevitably do—the BOE provides the context to understand why these deviations happened and what can be done about them.
Benefits of BOE Documentation:
- Audit Trail: Provides a comprehensive record of the estimation process, essential for audits and reviews.
- Baseline for Monitoring: Serves as a reference point for tracking project progress and managing deviations.
- Change Management: Facilitates the assessment of impacts from unexpected changes, ensuring project alignment with goals.
For GovCons, where projects are frequently subject to scrutiny and audits, the BOE is a critical piece of documentation. It offers the ability to trace the entire estimation process, providing evidence that every number in the estimate is backed by reasoning and reliable data. This facilitates smoother audits, reinforces the credibility of the entire project, and codifies valuable subject matter expertise.
The BOE also contributes to managing changes that arise during the project lifecycle. When unexpected developments occur, the BOE can be revisited to reassess the impact on the overall estimate. This ability to adapt and update the BOE ensures that the project remains aligned with its financial and operational goals, even as conditions evolve.
Building a Strong BOE Foundation
Constructing a BOE is a core discipline of the cost engineering process. It encapsulates the expertise, judgment, and diligence cost engineers bring, providing a transparent and credible foundation for project estimates.
Unison’s TrueBOE, available within the TruePlanning suite, helps streamline this process by allowing documentation at multiple levels—input, cost object, and project. With TrueBOE, cost engineers can easily attach notes, files, and supporting documentation, ensuring that every estimate is thoroughly documented and readily accessible for review. This solution enhances the BOE creation process, as well as its credibility and transparency.
BOE development and documentation are skills that support precise, repeatable, and reliable cost estimation. A well-crafted BOE reflects the professionalism and expertise that defines the field of cost engineering—ensuring every estimate is as solid as the engineering behind it.
.jpg)
